Hello Antonio,
I'm so glad you are enjoying the school.
I looked at the link to the chisels, and it is so difficult to say whether they are good quality or not by photographs. I am not familiar with this brand. The one thing that concerns me is the v-chisel has a LOT of metal - which causes it to be very awkward to use. It's difficult to see how thick the others are. It might be a good idea to get one basic curved gouge (maybe a #5, 14mm) and get it sharpened. Use it for a while on hard wood and see how hit holds up. Use it with a mallet and without mallet. Also, if it sharpens very fast, that is usually a good sign that it will dull quickly also. Sometimes these less expensive brands don't have a good temper on the end. I have heard that if you take it to a metal smith, they can temper the ends of these tools and make them very good tools.
I do know that one brand that is inexpensive, Master Carver series from Woodworkers supply (online school) is a Chinese brand averaging about $10 to $15 per tool. I bought one to test these out and it has held a good edge. They aren't pretty, don't generally come fully sharpened, and are not full length tools, but if you're just starting out, it might be a good set if you are on a budget. European made tools are the best, but can be pretty costly.
I also would be reluctant to purchase a "kit". Usually there are one or two tools in the kit that you will never use. Best to wait until a sale goes on for the tools and buy them individually.
I'm new around here.
But I can say immediately that your teachings are the kind i like. Simple and effective.
Until now I just did some "carved things" in my woodwork using pocket knife and a very inexpensive copy "of dremel".
Then I found Paul Sellers, Tom Fidgen, Roy Underhill, You and others. And move on to 90% hand tools.
I don't want to be a "carver" but just to explore a little bit more about carving in order to be able to include some had carved details in my furniture and toys.
So my question about budget chisels/gouges:
-Do you know "faithfull carving chisels" https://www.faithfulltools.com/c/c/Carving_Chisels - 6 Euros/ 7dollars each..)?
-Can you that you recommend any other inexpensive brand?
-Or its best to save some money and buy something like Pfeil 20 euros/26 dollars each for the starter kit?
I'm new around here.
But I can say immediately that your teachings are the kind i like. Simple and effective.
Until now I just did some "carved things" in my woodwork using pocket knife and a very inexpensive copy "of dremel".
Then I found Paul Sellers, Tom Fidgen, Roy Underhill, You and others. And move on to 90% hand tools.
I don't want to be a "carver" but just to explore a little bit more about carving in order to be able to include some had carved details in my furniture and toys.
So my question about budget chisels/gouges:
-Do you know "faithfull carving chisels" https://www.faithfulltools.com/c/c/Carving_Chisels - 6 Euros/ 7dollars each..)?
-Can you that you recommend any other inexpensive brand?
-Or its best to save some money and buy something like Pfeil 20 euros/26 dollars each for the starter kit?
I do like Stubai. They hold a good edge. I think in my collection I mostly have Dastra, Pfeil (Swiss Made) & Stubai. Usually any European made gouges are good quality.
Mary
I am very impressed with your wood carving lessons I have been working with wood for many years as a hobbyist and I am keen to get into wood carving I have read some books and bought some videos but your videos are the best I have found starting with the basics and then building the skills sets.
The question I have is what brand of carving chisels do you use / recommend. While live in Australia I do buy a lot of my wood tools from Lee Valley in Canada as they are a very reliable supplier. They have two brands Henry Taylor & Hirsch but the selection dose align with your recommended beginners list. And they only have a couple of fish tale gouges. I am a very tall person (6'6") with large hands to match so I do not want something with handles that are too small. And I do appreciate quality it tools.
Hello Murray,
Thanks so much for your encouraging feedback.
Tools are very difficult (and often difficult to find those perfect shapes). You may want to try Pfeil brand from Switzerland or Stubai brand from Austria. I'm not sure what their process is or how costly it would be to ship to Australia. Pfeil has almost all of the recommended sizes in fishtail. Hopefully within the next few months there will be fishtails available through Lie-Nielsen and Auriou. Just don't know how long that will take for them to start production of them.
Hello Mary
Have purchased the Pefeil gouges from Woodcraft in the USA, delivery to Australia was about a week. The quality of the steel looks and sounds good and they seem to sharpen easy enough. Just have to finish a couple of small projects and I will attempting the donut and flower. I will let you know how it goes.
Murray
With regards to the above message, I am on to it, I went to your links page and noticed the Woodcraft link. Have gone with the pfeil Swiss made. They have a huge selection; I ordered as per your beginners list and look forward to getting started.
From Mary May on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/08/02 at 10:43 am
From António Samagaio on All About Gouges
Go to comment2014/08/02 at 10:15 am
From António Samagaio on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/08/02 at 10:15 am
From bob dubasik on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/31 at 2:29 pm
From Mary May on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/31 at 3:32 pm
From bob dubasik on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/31 at 7:11 pm
From Murray Potts on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/25 at 11:22 pm
From Mary May on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/29 at 12:09 pm
From Murray Potts on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/08/06 at 8:42 am
From Murray Potts on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/26 at 3:00 am
From Mary May on All About Gouges - Beginner Lesson #3
Go to comment2014/07/29 at 12:10 pm